| |
The following
review of Applied Population Ecology was
published in The Quarterly Review of Biology, vol. 73, no. 3, pages
380-381, September 1998. It is reproduced here by permission of the
reviewer.
To succeed as a
professional ecologist or conservation biologist, one needs both a broad
conceptual understanding of the field and a set of quantitative tools for
analysing data and predicting outcomes. While most ecologists agree that our
subject is intrinsically quantitative, we often shy away from quantitative
topics in our courses. This is both because it requires considerable effort and
because we realize that "many people drawn to the fascination and beauty
of the qualitative aspects of ecology are put off by the quantitative
aspects" (M. Shaffer, Foreword). In response to such concerns, some
textbooks in ecology and (sadly) most in conservation biology avoid a rigorous
introduction to quantitative population models. While such approaches are
certainly justified in many situations, they also handicap students serious
about pursuing careers in ecology or conservation biology.
Fortunately, our
field is now blessed with Applied Population Ecology, an excellent
introduction to population models that facilitates the inclusion of
quantitative material in upper-level undergraduate and beginning graduate
courses. Students with even a modest background in mathematics are guided
step-by-step through a graduated series of explanations, examples, and
exercises designed to give them a firm grounding in how models of population
growth and regulation are used in ecology. The well-chosen examples range from
Muskox reintroduced to Nunivak Island through population explosions of humans,
to the erratic declines of threatened species like the Helmeted Honeyeater and
California Spotted Owl. These examples capture the interest of the reader, and
allow the book "to introduce mathematical ecology by developing an
intuitive understanding of the basic concepts and by motivating the students
through examples that put these concepts to practical use" (p xi).
In the first five
chapters, the authors concisely lay out the essentials of population growth and
its variability, population regulation, and the structure and dynamics of
age-structured and stage-structured models. The authors ably introduce key
quantitative concepts, emphasizing discrete time models and numerical
simulation which, they argue, are "more applicable ... and easier to
explain and understand" (p 26) than continuous time models and analysis.
In addition, such models allow them to embrace the stochastic nature of
demography at small population sizes and thus emphasize the variability and
unpredictability that rarely emerge when we teach by using the usual
deterministic models. This newer paradigm is explored via numerical examples in
both the text and the problems that appear at the end of each chapter. Many of
these exercises rely on the integrated EcoLab 1.0 software package for
simulating population processes that would otherwise require lengthy and
tedious calculation. Indeed, simulations provide the only practical way for
readers to explore such models, imparting an intuitive feel for modeling,
uncertainty, and the impact of chance events. Another compelling aspect of this
book is its surprisingly broad coverage of topics in conservation biology. This
emphasis accords well with current student interest and reflects the
authors active research interests (but may disappoint those expecting
more coverage of fisheries or wildlife management). The authors speak knowingly
of current and past problems in applying ecology successfully and refer
directly to their own experiences. They also present interesting asides that
enliven the text and effectively link concepts to important contemporary
issues.
The final three
chapters tackle the areas of metapopulations and spatial structure, population
viability analysis, and decision-making in natural resources management. While
coverage is necessarily less complete in these areas, the book touches on a
remarkable diversity of topics, including sensitivity analysis, corridors and
reserve design, the precautionary principle, type I and type II errors, and the
general problems presented when few data are available to make decisions. There
are also selective and informed choices for further reading at the end of each
chapter.
Applied Population
Ecology succeeds in teaching quantitative models while explaining the
context that makes these models important. Readers will gain quantitative
insights and opportunities to exercise their skills in a trim and readable
package. Instructors will gain an authoritative and pedagogically effective
tool for teaching core concepts thoroughly. If we join in the efforts of this
book to raise levels of numeracy in future cohorts of ecologists, our students,
the field, and perhaps even natural populations will benefit.
Don Waller, Botany, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin
|
| |
The following review of
Applied Population Ecology was published in
Fisheries vol. 22, no. 11, pages 47-48; November 1997, by Saul Saila.
"The book is
clearly written and well illustrated with examples. However, I believe it is
absolutely essential for most serious readers of this book to use the software
(RAMAS Ecolab) because it provides an intuitive understanding of otherwise
difficult concepts that are usually addressed mathematically.
...
"This book is
written in a tutorial fashion, and I recommend it highly to students of
fisheries science at an upper-undergraduate or early-graduate level as a
valuable adjunct to any beginning fishery science text. The book contains much
important information that is given little or no attention in conventional
texts.
...
"I also recommend
this book with almost equal enthusiasm to fishery managers who want to obtain a
painless reintroduction to matrix models or who want a better understanding of
many concepts relevant to important management decisions."
Saul B. Saila
Graduate School of Oceanography
Univeristy of Rhode Island
|